Book Club: Best of “Teach Your Children Well”

November 4, 2012 § Leave a comment

I’m still reading Part Two, and need another week. You?

Part Two of Teach Your Children Well, called “The ‘School Years’ Are Not Just About Academics”, is long and hard to break up. In addition, last week’s Book Club attendance was down due to hurricane Sandy and Halloween. So I decided I’m going to re-run last week’s talk again this Tuesday night, November 6, at 8:30 PM CST, for another live chat. It’s a good one, and deserves another shot. We’ll then cover the entire Part Two section, broken into three different parts, next Tuesday. 

Madeline Levine’s Teach Your Children Well is longer than our last book, and contains more information, too. I’m trying to get us finished up by Thanksgiving, so I decided to do all of Part Two next Tuesday night instead. If you are just beginning the book and want to catch up, check out our discussion on the introduction with author and educator Kurt Wootton. See you Tuesday night!

Book Club: Chapters 1 and 2 in “Teach Your Children Well”

October 30, 2012 § 5 Comments

Welcome to the real-time Parent Book Club chat! To have access to all the comments and replies, please click on the title of this post; the post will go to a new page, and comments will be located at the bottom of the post. To see new comments/replies, just hit your refresh button from time to time. For more discussion, follow me on Twitter here or on Facebook here. Thanks!

According to psychologist Madeline Levine, one of the reasons we parents can’t see that we’ve gone crazy over caring for our kids is because we are too busy – overscheduled and overcommitted ourselves, we’ve simply failed to notice that changes in culture and technology may be unmooring us. In Chapter 2 of Teach Your Children Well, Levine says,

“Perhaps we have become so seduced by the possibility of being able to cultivate ‘outstanding’ children because we are a bit lost ourselves. Technology has revolutionized communication. While smartphones, tablets, Skype, Facebook, and LinkedIn increasingly connect us they can paradoxically make us feel disconnected as we devote less time to basic human needs for empathic, resonant communication, eye contact, and touch. Increased mobility robs us of the stable community that once provided the emotional resources to weather the challenges of child rearing. Instead we are immersed in a culture that emphasizes individuality, competition, and self-centeredness. This cannot possibly nourish our own needs adequately, and it often leads us to feel isolated and even a little bit desperate. We hunker down and immerse ourselves in our children’s activities at the expense of adult relationships and our own continued development. Decreasing the sphere of our own lives makes us increasingly dependent on our children for a sense of meaning and accomplishment.”

Ouch.

Since the first two chapters of the book – “The Kids are Not All Right” and “How Did we Get into This Mess?” – clearly address the parents, I thought it would only be fitting if Parent Book Club addressed us tonight. So, for tonight anyway, forget the kids. According to Levine, our kids don’t receive the message that life is a series of high-pressure pass/fail tests, devoid of free time or play, from the ether; evidently, they are getting the idea that life is a performance, and a chore, from us. Levine emphasizes over and over in these first two chapters how modern parents have no time for themselves, and many of the parents she knows have carved out little time for their own hobbies and friendships. (Ostensibly because they are “too busy” and life is too demanding to have the time.) But why is this? She suggests that parents put their children first at ever opportunity, choosing to do for their kids and careers what they dare not do for themselves. Levine even goes so far as to point out that people who only fulfill the needs of others on a constant basis are going to feel overwhelmed, overscheduled, desperate, and depressed – the exact emotions she sees in her young patients. Could it be that we parents are modeling the very behavior causing so much distress in our kids?

And, let’s be honest, it’s causing distress to us, too, if we took the time to admit it. But until we admit that it’s a problem, we can’t fix it. I can’t help but think of a moving article I read recently about the happy, healthy, relaxed inhabitants of the Greek island of Ikaris, called, unnervingly, “The Island Where People Forget to Die.” The long-lived residents, who work in their gardens, get up when they feel like it, and stay up all night playing dominos and drinking wine, seem to have openly admitted the secret to life – having fun. I couldn’t help but contrast it with my own current situation: we rush from one half-assed activity to another, and whenI do see other parents, we complain about how busy we are, and how we wish we could be less so. Looking at why kids can’t be kids in our current culture, I can’t help but see Levine’s point: we are doing nothing more than showing our children their future, and the future is this – life is a chore, created to be endured.

Not to say that there isn’t meaningful work, or pride and accomplishment in doing something well. But have we fallen over the deep end entirely? This book suggests that it’s a possibility.

The one burning question I had after finishing these two honest chapters is the subject of tonight’s talk.

Tonight’s Talk: How on earth do we possibly change our own behavior? What are the things you are doing to resist the temptation of throwing yourself into everything but yourself – including your kids’ lives? Or, are you safely out of the danger zone – enjoying your own activities, career, friends, life? If so, please share your secrets.

I am so looking forward to reading what you have to say!

Bonus Material: Kurt Wootton and “Teach Your Children Well”

October 26, 2012 § 1 Comment

Tuesday night’s Parent Book Club on “Teach Your Children Well” was so packed with information that Kurt and I decided to cut a part of his terrific essay, “Dance Like No One’s Watching.” But after re-reading the parts we cut, and talking with my father, who (also) taught public school for his entire career, I decided that these small but important bits are vitally important to another part of the discussion: if we are going to foster true learning and help kids develop a roadmap for authentic success, we’re going to have to talk about teaching, too.

Here’s the part of Kurt’s essay that didn’t make it:

My father, who was a public school teacher, told me once that teaching in a large, traditional, neighborhood school isn’t a sprint—it’s a marathon. One of my colleagues who teaches English in a Boston Public School sees 140 students every day. We know that giving students multiple choice tests, pop quizzes, and other quick assessments doesn’t truly measure their learning, but you can imagine how long it takes to grade an essay. Let’s do some quick math: 140 students x 10 minutes to read and grade a paper = 23.34 hours. That’s time spent outside of school and doesn’t include the planning time needed to prepare classes. You can see why teachers and school districts might take shortcuts by giving students multiple-choice tests that can be graded by a machine. 

The morning after Parent Book Club, my dad called to talk about ‘authentic success’ and the innovative classroom teaching that leads to tinkering, investigating, and deeper learning for students. When I told him what Kurt’s dad had said, he backed it up, and added, “There are teachers who are taking the material and presenting it in innovative ways; there are lots of creative teachers out there, no doubt. But the combination of factors that a teacher faces on a daily basis make it extremely difficult to sustain.”

We forget many times that teachers are people, too; they have families and friends and bills to pay. I know an extra unpaid 23+ hours a week would make me cranky. Yet if we are gearing our kids toward authentic success, and want them to be less focused on grades and test scores (and therefore less stressed out, depressed and freer to enjoy learning), then we must address the way the current system works – and its dogged chase of, well, grades and test scores. After re-reading this cut paragraph a few times, I got frustrated and emailed Kurt.

“What can we do about this?” I typed testily. It was only a few minutes later that I received a long, detailed list of why the school system is unable to support the kind of open-ended learning we are talking about in reference to Levine’s book – besides the obvious time constraints. He rattled off ways in which teacher development could be better, more creative, and involve teachers’ self-reflection more, and Kurt was quick to mention that it’s a complex issue and shouldn’t be looked at in clear black-and-white, but still I wanted to share a few key nuggets of the long list he wrote at 10PM:

  • ” A radically wrong-minded emphasis on testing and the results.”
  • “High student workload and little planning time. Some teachers teach 140 students a week with a 45 minute planning period during the day. They are exhausted and they are just trying to get by.”
  • “Lack of possibility and opportunity. Many teachers don’t know about and schools don’t support radical teacher professional development (like the Habla Teacher Institute.) Teachers should have the chance to travel, to take summer courses in universities, and to work with diverse organizations—and schools should pay for it!”
  • But here’s the kicker, the one that really got me: “Lack of valuing exploration and creativity from a policy and administrative level. This relates back to 1 (testing and results), but creativity can’t be quantifiably measured. It’s more difficult to evaluate learning in a creative space, and therefore the “effectiveness” of an education environment.  Great teaching and learning is messy and a bit chaotic.”

Hmmm. It seems that administrators and policy makers should join our Parent Book Club, so they could also read “Teach Your Children Well,” and see what lack of valuing exploration and creativity is doing to our kids in the long haul.

Parent Book Club: Intro to “Teach Your Children Well” with Guest Moderator Kurt Wootton

October 23, 2012 § 41 Comments

Welcome to the real-time Parent Book Club chat! To have access to all the comments and replies, please click on the title of this post; the post will go to a new page, and comments will be located at the bottom of the post. To see new comments/replies, just hit your refresh button from time to time. For more discussion, follow me on Twitter here or on Facebook here. Thanks!

Tonight’s discussion will be led and moderated by 20-year teaching veteran and author Kurt Wootton. He is cofounder of the ArtsLiteracy Project in the Education Department at Brown University, and he is currently the director of Habla: The Center for Language and Culture, an ArtsLiteracy lab school in Merida, Mexico. His first book, A Reason to Read: Linking Literacy and the Arts, was written with Eileen Landay and recently published by Harvard University Press. He is also a relatively new parent: his daughter is a little over two years old. (Go here for full bio.)

Kurt has so kindly written tonight’s post and discussion question on the introduction to Madeline Levine’s Teach Your Children Well.   He will also be around to comment and reply to your thoughts and questions. We are so excited to have him! Welcome, Kurt!

Dance Like No One’s Watching, by Kurt Wootton

Think back to a classroom experience that looked something like: a) read a chapter in the textbook; b) fill out some worksheets; c) listen to the teacher lecture; d) take a multiple choice test; e) repeat the process throughout the entire school year. This was my, and probably your, experience in many classes: algebra, history, physics, biology, chemistry. We view students as “successful” if they are able to consistently and quickly memorize large quantities of information the night before a test. If students do this throughout their school career their classmates and teachers will call them “smart,” even if they can’t think through a complex problem, collaborate with classmates, or create something original. The formula of teaching students facts and then testing them is very easy. We know who is the “best” student and who is the “worst.” We know who should be in the honor society or who is the valedictorian, but we aren’t developing and rewarding the broad range of diverse skills and talents our students bring to the academic environment.

Madeline Levine, in her book Teach Your Children Well, encourages us to move beyond valuing such superficial accomplishments and push ourselves and our children to embrace what she refers to as “authentic success.” Madeline notes that, “We know far too much about promoting healthy child development to continue to tolerate the myth that success is a straight and narrow path, with childhood sacrificed in the process. The truth is that most successful people have followed winding paths, have had false starts, and have enjoyed multiple careers.” We spend so much time in our schools assessing our students with micro-tasks—problems sets, quizzes, tests, papers—we either push students away from school, or, for those that choose to play the game, as Levine notes, they often become sleep-deprived, stressed, anxious, or even depressed.

Learning should be about taking the time to contemplate the questions of the universe. Imagine a physics teacher walking into her classroom and explaining to the students, “This year you will work in groups to try to do what Einstein wasn’t able to: to construct an overall physical theory of the universe. First you need some background information. Let’s start with Newton.” Or imagine an English teacher saying, “We read to understand who we are as human beings. We’ll consider what Hamlet’s problems have to do with our own, and by the end of this course you just might see your life in a different way.” In these classes the chance at arriving at a “correct” answer is largely out of the question. But imagine the journey!

Contrary to what many parents might think, even the road to external success is windier than it would appear. I taught for many years in an Ivy League school. Most of my students weren’t perfect academically in high school, but they were nearly all interesting. It seemed that the admissions office was not looking for the seemingly perfect student, the ones who always filled in the correct bubble. There were plenty of those applying. They wanted students who had a strong sense of integrity and a passion for something. There was Daveed the fabulous hip-hop lyricist and Jody who could dance like Michael Jackson. I remember one of my students, Liz, who wrote a top ten list of why the school should accept her, rather than writing the college essay. When I asked her about it for this article, she wrote me:

I did write a top ten list for my college essay; how on earth do you remember that? I’m pretty sure it was full of “dance like no one’s watching”-esque nuggets and Bob Dylan lyrics, though for some reason they let me in anyway.

These were students who had followed their bliss, to use writer Joseph Campbell’s term, and it showed.

Perhaps all of us as teachers and parents must work to do less talking and more listening—less cajoling and more observing. We need to help our young people find what they are passionate about and nurture those passions at home and in school. Madeline offers this definition of “authentic success”:

“Authentic success is being ‘the best me I can be’ not simply in isolation, but as part of a community, and it always includes a component of meaningful contribution and connection with others.”

Tonight’s Talk: What are authentic successes and what are the various ways we, as parents and teachers, can work to help our young people achieve them rather than the superficial ones our schools and society often demand?

I look forward to the conversation.

“Teach Your Children Well” #PBC Resources

October 19, 2012 § Leave a comment

We are gearing up for a very exciting Monday night Parent Book Club discussion led by author and educator Kurt Wootton. I have seen Kurt’s post introducing the book and covering the introduction, and it is outstanding! You are not going to want to miss this exciting discussion! Join us at 8:30 PM CST this coming Monday, October 22. Invite your friends. We are going to talk about education, parenting, and what it means to own”authentic success.” 

In the meantime, here are some related resources I thought you might enjoy. If you haven’t done so, grab the book and join us Monday night!

New York Times Review of “Teach Your Children Well” by Judith Warner

Warner writes, “This message — that, essentially, every­thing today’s parents think they’re doing right is actually wrong - is the most noteworthy take-away from… this book.

“The Ego in Raising Successful Children” at NYT Motherlode blog

Motherlode editor KJ Dell’Antonia notices, “I begin to suspect that we do all this discussing and ruminating, as Ms. Levine put it, ‘out of our own needs rather than theirs.’ How egotistical is it to think that my parenting skills shape my children’s every action?”

“Teach Your Children Well: An Interview With Psychologist and Author Madeline Levine” at HuffPost

I liked this bit of the interview so much, I posted it on my Facebook page, but here it is again, straight from Levine’s mouth: “When I say overparenting is not a great idea, I’m really talking about three things: Don’t do for your kid what they can already do. Don’t do for your kid what they can almost do, because that’s where they have those successful failures. Sometimes they make it; sometimes they don’t — but that’s where they learn. And don’t do for your kids out of your needs, not theirs. That’s my quick definition of overparenting.”

Browse Inside “Teach Your Children Well” by Madeline Levine

Harper Collins give you a chance to read a bit of the book before you buy; also provides links to online booksellers

Parent Book Club book “How Children Succeed”

Parent Book Club’s take on a related book, “How Children Succeed” by Paul Tough, and research on how character traits like grit and perseverance may prove to be more important to success than academics, test scores, and IQs.

Guest Moderator Kurt Wootton Joins Parent Book Club

October 16, 2012 § 4 Comments

Parent Book Club is very excited to announce that educator, author and consultant Kurt Wootton will blog and moderate the introduction segment of  Madeline Levine’s “Teach Your Children Well” on Tuesday night, October 23, at 8:30 PM CST. Here’s a little bit about Kurt and why you need to join us for this exciting, enlightening discussion!

Kurt Wootton is a 20-year veteran teacher and expert in integrating literacy and the arts. He is cofounder of the ArtsLiteracy Project in the Education Department at Brown University, and he is currently the director of Habla: The Center for Language and Culture, an ArtsLiteracy lab school in Merida, Mexico. His first book, A Reason to Read: Linking Literacy and the Arts, was written with Eileen Landay and recently published by Harvard University Press. He is also a relatively new parent: his daughter is a little over two years old. (Go here for full bio.)

Kurt is also my friend. We performed in high school productions of “The Music Man” and “Hello, Dolly!” together; we both have fathers who taught public school. But, most importantly, we have had many discussions about the role of education in children’s lives (especially over email); he has guided much of the thinking that helped me become the education writer I am today; I attended an Habla conference put on by Kurt and his wife Marimar that changed the way I thought about learning. It is for all these reasons that I thought Kurt was the perfect person to investigate the introduction to psychologist Levine’s guide to authentic parenting. I can’t wait to hear what Kurt has to say about the book – his perspective as a teacher and a parent, what he thinks are the biggest takeaways, and how he thinks parents might be able to use Levine’s argument going forward.

So, why wouldn’t you join us for Tuesday’s intro session on Teach Your Children Well? Get your book today and dig into the introduction, then come back Tuesday night at 8:30 PM CST to share your thoughts!

The Next #PBC Pick: Teach Your Children Well

October 9, 2012 § Leave a comment

“This message — that, essentially, every­thing today’s parents think they’re doing right is actually wrong - is the most noteworthy take-away from… this book.” Judith Warner, The New York Times

From reading How Children Succeed, we learned our kids need grit – perseverance, optimism, and self-control, too – but how do we go about teaching that? What’s the best way to give our kids the tools to be independent, strong and happy?

With this in mind, I am thrilled to introduce our next book club pick: child psychologist Madeline Levine’s Teach Your Children Well. The book’s jacket says, “Parents, educators, and the media wring their hands about the plight of America’s children and teens—soaring rates of emotional problems, limited coping skills, disengagement from learning and yet there are ways to reverse these disheartening trends. Teach Your Children Well acknowledges that every parent wants successful children. However, until we are clearer about our core values and the parenting choices that are most likely to lead to authentic, and not superficial, success, we will continue to raise exhausted, externally driven, impaired children who believe they are only as good as their last performance. Real success is always an inside job, argues Levine, and is measured not by today’s report card but by the people our children become fifteen or twenty years down the line.”

Parenting, Levine says, is a long-term gig, but today’s parents might be too focused on immediate rewards. It’s no mystery that many upper- and upper-middle class parents are confused about what to give their kids: Paul Tough himself used the words “the trophy generation” on national TV to describe the culture of reward, outward success, and constant achievement engendered by parents who only want the best for their kids. Yet, in the haste to produce successful children, are we parents pushing too hard, and pushing the wrong things? Are our kids learning the wrong lessons – both about their relationships and their futures?

Sure to be controversial and engaging, challenging our deepest questions about parenting and the role of parents in an uncertain world of constant change, Teach Your Children Well should be an exciting read for parents who want to change the path that they are on, or add new tools to a parenting style that favors the long-term goals over short-term success.

Get the book now! We will have our first real-time, online chat Monday night, October 22 at 8:30 CST. 

 

 

Kidapps's Blog

iPhone and iPad Reviews for Games for Kids

you found me.

game designer, author, future forecaster, PhD

The Manifest-Station

A Place For Words.

Wright'sRoom

Pondering education, technology, and making a difference

goodbyemisterhunter

Robert Peal on education and reform

To Be Aware

It's all about disbelieving your thoughts

The Children's Ark Preparatory School, Philippines

Emotional Quotient:Academic Excellence

New York Observer

News and commentary, authoritative and sophisticated, for influencers in New York and around the country, particularly politics, culture, lifestyle and real estate.

nick courtright. poet, editor, and educator.

husband to michelle, father to william and samuel

NIKHIL GOYAL

"Kicking bureaucratic ass and taking names."—Upworthy

Laura Grace Weldon

Free Range Learning, Relentless Optimism, Creative Living, Gentle Encouragement, Occasional Sarcasm

Gallerist

Daily chronicle of the art world for artists, gallery owners and collectors

engaged intellectuals

critical educators merging life and pedagogy working toward social justice

The Skeptic Detective

Science, Skepticism, Atheism

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 815 other followers